Political Quotes

On the recordMarch 22, 2012
It is my position that within the good that this does is a poison pill. The good is that consumers would also benefit from a repeal of McCarran-Ferguson. We salute you. But the poison pill is that this measure would ban class actions on a claim for violation of antitrust law, which is the cleverest way of ending antitrust law. Unless you have a class action--well, my doctor-Congressman is not a lawyer, but without class actions, you can't bring a claim because nobody's going to file a suit on a $30 issue, 1 million people suing for $30 each. So it's a poison pill. I'd like to yield such time as he may consume to the gentleman from Oregon (Mr. DeFazio), who had an amendment that had huge bipartisan support. Mr. DeFAZIO. I thank the gentleman for yielding. We had, at the end of last Congress, a tremendous bipartisan vote-- 406 19--on repealing straight up the antitrust immunity of the insurance industry. The American people, no matter where they are on the Affordable Care Act, agree on one thing: insurance companies should not be able to get together and collude to either exclude people from coverage or drive up prices. Yet they do. They have an exemption under a law from the 1940s. Now, what the gentleman is offering sounds pretty good, but it won't get us there because 90 percent of the antitrust cases are private, and almost every single one of those cases is a class action.…
Said by
John Conyers
Democratic · Michigan
Source
govinfo.gov
Mar 22, 2012

Share

More from John Conyers

Oct 3, 2017

I demand a recorded vote. A recorded vote was ordered. The SPEAKER pro tempore. This will be a 5-minute vote. The vote was taken by electronic device, and there were--ayes 237, noes 189, not voting 7, as follows: [Roll No. 549] AYES--237…

govinfo.gov
Sep 9, 2019

You got a good point, but we are going to be able to get it passed. Let's let it go to the courts.

congress.gov
Nov 6, 2017

On Sunday, a gunman shot and killed 26 churchgoers in Sutherland Springs, Texas.

congress.gov
Oct 31, 2017

I am a cosponsor of her legislation with great pride.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation