Mr. Speaker, this is a gag rule pure and simple. It is not needed at this particular time. There is plenty of time to deal with this legislation. If we pass this legislation tomorrow or today, the other body will not be able to move on it until after they come back. If we pass it the day after we come back from the recess, the other body can still consider the legislation within sufficient time to meet the June 30 deadline. Mr. Speaker, I rise in opposition, and I say this with great respect for my good friend, the chairman of the Committee on Rules, the gentleman from New York, who has given us another gag rule. I also object to the extraordinary way in which this bill was brought to the floor and the way in which the minority's rights have been trampled. There are two rules that have been dealt with unfavorably: One is the 3-day requirement with regard to the minority having opportunity to file minority views, and the other is a provision which requires a 3-day layover. Neither of these needs to be waived at this time. This is a closed rule. It is an unfair rule. It is a restrictive rule. It prevents Members from offering amendments other than one substitute that requires any and all amendments to be packaged into one, regardless of whether they are consistent with each other.
On the recordApril 6, 1995
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Opposing a closed rule for legislation during House floor debate.
Share
More from Debbie Dingell
Apr 28, 2025
I thank Chairman Guthrie. I thank Ranking Member, Frank Pallone, who often puts up with my intensity on this subject. I also thank Chairman Bilirakis and my co-leads, Representatives Salazar, Dean, and Pfluger, as well as Senator Cruz and…
Apr 28, 2025
In closing, I strongly urge that my colleagues on both sides of the aisle support H.R. 906, the Foreign Adversary Communications Transparency Act for the security of our Nation. I yield back the balance of my time.
Aug 18, 2026
I believe that that was a very deliberate effort to vote, and that that person, individual, signed an affidavit saying that he was an American citizen and eligible to vote.





