Political Quotes

On the recordSeptember 24, 1997
I will be voting for the amendment offered by the ranking member of the subcommittee. The effort to get a Supreme Court decision on the census before we take the census simply will not work. The American Constitution is very clear. For once I wish some of my colleagues paid more attention to the very clear writing of Justice Scalia. You cannot by statute constitute the U.S. Supreme Court as an advisory body to tell us in advance of what happens. There is an amendment that says you cannot go forward with the census sampling until the Supreme Court has decided it, but the Supreme Court will disregard this. Have we not learned from what happened with the line-item veto? The requirement that there be an actual case or controversy and an aggrieved party is something that is strictly enforced by the U.S. Supreme Court. Mr. Speaker, if Members want to ban sampling, they ought to offer that as a vote. I would not be for it. But no one should console themselves that we can vote to have the Supreme Court by our instruction take a case which constitutionally they will not take and then have solved the problem.
Said by
Barney Frank
Democratic · Massachusetts

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the implications of a Supreme Court decision on the census during a House floor debate.

Share

More from Barney Frank

Jul 11, 2016

The Supreme Court says we have a right to be married. There is no Federal legislation and in many States no other legislation that protects us against discrimination.

congress.gov
Nov 12, 2019

Congress generally, and this subcommittee in particular has historically played a critical role in strengthening accountability at the World Bank.

congress.gov
Apr 5, 2017

For example, there are key differences in product characteristics between payday, car title, and other high-cost secured loans and more traditional closed-end unsecured lending and related products, and the products are often regulated…

congress.gov
Jul 11, 2016

They shouldn't lose their tax-exempt status but neither should they be able to go for a Federal grant as they would be under this bill.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation