Political Quotes

John Hostettler: Why are we considering this legislation today? How is the offering of prayer at a football game unconstitutional? The…

On the recordNovember 2, 1999
Why are we considering this legislation today? How is the offering of prayer at a football game unconstitutional? The root of this debate can be traced to 1962 when the Supreme Court opined in Engel versus Vitale that, quote, State-sponsored, end quote, prayer was unconstitutional. Why? Because the Supreme Court said that the First Amendment had erected a wall of separation between church and State and that wall had been applied to the individual States by way of the Fourteenth Amendment. Where did that logic come from? It was a line of reasoning that was expounded by Justice Hugo Black in 1947 when he stated, quote, my study of the historical events that culminated in the Fourteenth Amendment and the expression of those who sponsored and favored, as well as those who opposed its submission and passage, persuades me that the provision of the amendment's first section were intended to make the Bill of Rights applicable to the States, end quote.
Said by
John Hostettler
Indiana

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the constitutionality of prayer at football games and referencing Supreme Court decisions.

Share

More from John Hostettler

Jul 10, 2002

Once again, Mr. Chairman, the amendment I offer simply opens up the bill and the provisions of the bill to all the pilots that desire to take part in this program, that volunteer to take part in this program, and does not discriminate…

govinfo.gov
May 11, 2006

Special Operations Forces have played an increasingly important role in our wars against nonstate actors. Therefore, I believe we need to encourage our Nation's best and brightest military scholars to focus on the scholarly research needs…

govinfo.gov
Jul 10, 2002

this amendment that I am proposing today would clarify what I believe this bill infers. Air carriers would simply be prevented from firing or otherwise discouraging those pilots who join the flight deck officer program. It also ensures…

govinfo.gov
Oct 8, 2004

I join the gentleman from Wisconsin (Chairman Sensenbrenner) in opposing this amendment, which would take a vital tool out of the hands of our Border Patrol in keeping foreign terrorists out of the United States. As it is distressingly…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation