I rise to praise the Constitution, but also appropriately perhaps in this setting, the Senate's foremost expositor and defender of that document, the Honorable Robert C. Byrd, who has today helped write a page in the history of liberty. In 1995, led by Senator Byrd, Senator Levin, Senator Hatfield and others, we pleaded with the Senate not to do this, not to enact this legislation. We said it is unconstitutional. That is a large statement. We did not say it was unwise or unseasonal. We said it was unconstitutional. We take an oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic, and domestic enemies can arise from ignorance, well-intentioned ignorance. This surely was the case, because the bill passed 69 to 31. It passed in the face of the clearest injunction from George Washington in 1793 who said, I must sign a bill in toto or veto it. Senator Byrd, along with the Senator from New York and Senators Levin and Hatfield, chose, with two Members of the House, to sue the Government of the United States declaring this act to be unconstitutional.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the constitutionality of legislation and the role of Senator Robert C. Byrd.
Share
More from Patrick Moynihan
That would be four months ago, in mid-May. There has been plenty of time to examine it. The House bill has a few additional features we find attractive and which we think we could adopt and send right to the President who would sign it. It…
Did you say the ``little State of Delaware''? Do you mean the first State to ratify the Constitution of the United States?
I wholly agree with the statement by our revered chairman of the Finance Committee. The operative part of this measure is two pages. It is a simple statement. It came out from the Finance Committee almost unanimously.
I think the Senator, the chairman of our committee, has spoken so well and effectively; the Senator from Montana equally so. I believe this debate has been thorough. We respect our friend from South Carolina. We know his views. We do not…





