I just want to say, implicit in this amendment as well as in the last one, is a denigration of the Federal bench; an assertion that they are incapable of judging whether an acquisition of evidence was in good faith, by an objectively reasonable standard; or whether the public, the long-suffering, victimized public, is better served by the admission of this evidence of guilt or not. But to carve out exceptions for various Federal agencies not only is insulting to those agencies--and that may or may not be true, but this is not the place to direct those insults--but it also demeans the bench, the Federal bench. I do not think we should overlook that. The whole point of the exercise today in passing this legislation is to give relief to the American public in situations where technicalities have been throwing out evidence where people otherwise should have been given the chance and court should have been given the chance to convict the bad guys. It is not to try to open the door in any way to reduce or relax the standards of the fourth amendment protections against unlawful search and seizures.
Editor's note · Context
Addressing concerns about amendments that may undermine the integrity of the Federal judiciary.
Share
More from Henry Hyde
Well, reclaiming my time, Madam Speaker, I thank the gentleman, but the Bush administration is on your side, not mine, this time.
I simply want to say, in response to my friend, the gentlewoman from California (Ms. Lee), that contempt is not animating our legislation, and I really question the wisdom of penetrating motives, which seems to be a habit with some people…
the reason this vote is so important is simply because the embryo is human life. It is not animal, it is not vegetable, it is not mineral, but a tiny, microscopic beginning of a human life. Everyone in this room was an embryo at one time…
I rise in support of H.R. 5682, the U.S.- India Nuclear Cooperation Promotion Act of 2006, which the Committee on International Relations ordered reported by a vote of 37-5 on June 28. This, therefore, is truly a bipartisan effort. This…





