Political Quotes

On the recordJuly 22, 2004
I think this is a wonderful debate. It is something that I have waited for years to listen to, because these are very important questions and the Constitution is everybody's business. It is certainly ours. What we are really debating is what does Article III, Section 1, clause 1 mean. The power to court strip, is it there, and if it is there, why is it a mortal sin for Congress to exercise it? I do not know. The Court is not the only repository of wisdom, nor of due process. We could have a seminar some day on the first amendment. Why does the establishment clause dominate jurisprudence concerning the relationship of religion and the State, but not the free exercise, which is ignored, which withers on the vine? What about the 10th amendment, which says all matters not enumerated to the Court are reserved to the people? It is ignored. It has been ignored for generations. So as we raise up the Court as the sole repository of wisdom and justice and fair play, we are not very historical because they are capable of abuses, too. Now, democracy requires checks and balances. We know that. What is the check and balance on the Supreme Court? Unelected, these are people who are well connected and they get confirmed, and they are imperial in their scope, and no check and balance whatsoever. Now, I would rather have a check and balance on the Court, just as I want one on the Congress, and the best check and balance is the people, the people who do the electing.
Said by
Henry Hyde
Illinois

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the role of the Supreme Court and the need for checks and balances in the government.

Share

More from Henry Hyde

Oct 7, 2004

while there may be some provisions in the Menendez substitute that are worthy of discussion during conference, I still rise in opposition to his amendment. Our review of the Commission's report was performed with a seriousness and a…

govinfo.gov
May 22, 2006

the election of Hamas to a majority within the Palestinian Legislative Council and to the formation of a terrorist organization-led government in the Palestinian Authority poses a serious challenge to the United States and its allies. The…

govinfo.gov
Mar 15, 2006

after 7 years of work on anti-narcotic efforts in Colombia, we are now seeing the fruits of our labors in the drug wars. Americans, and especially our young people, are greatly benefiting here at home from our policies in Colombia and the…

govinfo.gov
Jun 17, 2005

I simply want to say, in response to my friend, the gentlewoman from California (Ms. Lee), that contempt is not animating our legislation, and I really question the wisdom of penetrating motives, which seems to be a habit with some people…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation