Political Quotes

On the recordApril 19, 1994
Mr. Chairman, in response to the gentleman from Massachusetts, he said it happens, innocent people get convicted. Yes; and they get saved by habeas corpus under current law. All of this 40 percent that got their convictions turned around because of incompetent counsel, they were benefited by current law. So it happens that they are saved. Now, we do not need to attenuate the process decades into the future, meanwhile causing great pain and anguish to the families of the victims who wonder if justice will ever be done. Yes, retroactivity is covered under Teague versus Lane. And what the Derrick amendment does is redefine what a new rule is to make everything an old rule, to make Teague versus Lane inoperative, so that more and more and more petitions can be brought. The idea of multiple petitions, however, is from your own language, not yours, my friend from Massachusetts, but the gentleman from South Carolina [Mr. Derrick] and the gentleman from Texas [Mr. Laughlin], when they say, 'Our substitute,' speaking of their substitute, 'says these petitions,' plural, 'may only be heard if they go to the defendant's guilt or legal eligibility for the death sentence.' Well, that seems to me like multiple petitions.
Said by
Henry Hyde
Illinois

Editor's note · Context

Debating the implications of the Derrick amendment on habeas corpus and the justice system.

Share

More from Henry Hyde

Jun 17, 2005

if I may reclaim my time, I want to say to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. Gohmert), this is a marvelous amendment. The spirit in which it is offered is exemplary, and it is a very difficult thing to oppose it. But I see a problem with it…

govinfo.gov
Jul 19, 2005

someone once said brevity is the soul of eloquence. I shall attempt to emulate that by saying we are happy to accept this excellent amendment.

govinfo.gov
Oct 26, 2005

I rise in support of the Hyde-Lantos amendments to S. 1713, a bill passed by the Senate on September 21, 2005 amending the Iran Nonproliferation Act of 2000 to authorize new payments to Russia in support of the international space station…

govinfo.gov
Sep 29, 2021

I certainly would like to prevent, if I could legally, anybody having an abortion--a rich woman, a middle-class woman, or a poor woman.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation