My last question to the Senator: If this sense of the Congress is not worth the paper it is written on, as the Senator has said, is it fair to conclude that since the HMOs and managed care companies prevailed before when the Senator from Massachusetts offered his Patients' Bill of Rights to protect individuals from insurance companies making medical decisions, is it fair to conclude that if S. 11 were enacted as written, limiting the liability of these HMO and insurance companies, these companies would win again, that we would reward them again for bad conduct, despite the sense of the Senate, sense of Congress, section 13 of this bill?
Dick Durbin: “My last question to the Senator: If this sense of the Congress is not worth the paper it is written on, as the Senator…”
On the recordJuly 8, 2003
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Questioning the implications of S. 11 on HMO and insurance company liability.
Share
More from Dick Durbin
Oct 9, 2026
We ask that you immediately provide all committee records that you have withheld, commit to fully complying with Senate Rules XXVI and XXVII going forward, and apologize to Mr. Smith on behalf of the Committee.
Oct 14, 2026
Transferring immigrants to Guantánamo Bay is simply unlawful, and worse yet, inhumane.
Oct 10, 2026
The lowering of the FBI's hiring standards "threaten[s] to undermine the work of the FBI and pose a grave risk to the Bureau's integrity.
Oct 13, 2026
You can’t survive in politics unless you’re optimistic. You’ve got to believe that even though you face a setback or you don’t have all the laws you need, that tomorrow will be better.





