Political Quotes

Cord Byrd: So I come to the conjunction ``but''--paragraph 1, section 7, article I, of the U.S. Constitution. Here is what it says…

On the recordDecember 12, 2001
So I come to the conjunction ``but''--paragraph 1, section 7, article I, of the U.S. Constitution. Here is what it says: but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills. Now, we all know that when fast track is brought to the Senate, Senators may not propose amendments. In my way of reading the Constitution, that is not in accordance with what the Constitution says. What did the Framers mean? It is obvious that they meant the Senate could amend on any bill. Let me read the whole section again, the whole paragraph, section 7: All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but---- B-U-T---- the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills. It doesn't say it ``shall.'' The Senate may not want to offer any amendments, but it ``may.'' But now we come along with this so-called trade promotion authority. Ha, what a misnomer that is. And that is plain old fast track. And a lot of Senators and House Members are going to go to their oblivion on fast track if the people back home ever wake up to what is going on. . . . but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills. It doesn't say ``on some other Bills'' or ``on certain other Bills.'' It says ``as on other Bills.'' It seems to me the Senate has a right to amend.
Said by
Cord Byrd
Florida

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the Senate's authority to propose amendments during debate on trade promotion authority.

Share

More from Cord Byrd

May 1, 2008

I am saddened to learn that Mr. Johnny H. Killian has passed away. Mr. Killian was a highly regarded, highly admired, and highly utilized specialist in American public law at the Congressional Research Service. For more than four decades…

govinfo.gov
Jun 19, 2008

certain dates on the calendar carry special meaning. These are great and glorious days that are given to devoted reverence and are a cause for recognition and adoration. Thanksgiving, the Fourth of July, and New Year's Eve are a few dates…

govinfo.gov
Jan 15, 2009

on this cold January morning, I am being kept warm by four glorious words that keep running through my mind-- those four words are: ``Vice President Joe Biden.'' I love the sound of that. It is music to my ears. I have known Joe Biden for…

govinfo.gov
May 6, 2010

I oppose the Shelby amendment. In our zeal to protect consumers from egregious banking and lending practices, I fear the Senate is paying too little attention to basic constitutional tenets. The Shelby amendment proposes to create a…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation