Political Quotes

John Shadegg: We have this chart which makes the point that the gentleman just brought up. The burden of tobacco taxes falls largely…

On the recordOctober 30, 2007
We have this chart which makes the point that the gentleman just brought up. The burden of tobacco taxes falls largely on poor Americans. As a matter of fact, 28 percent of the people who smoke are considered poor. They make less than 100 percent of the poverty level. And 26 percent of the people who smoke are near-poor. They are in that 100 to 200 percent. And for the not-poor, that is only 18 percent of Americans. So this tobacco tax that is supposed to pay for the bill, but it is not enough money to pay for the bill unless millions of Americans, 22 million, take up smoking, post the burden of this legislation on the people who can least afford to pay it.
Said by
John Shadegg
Arizona

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the impact of tobacco taxes on low-income Americans.

Share

More from John Shadegg

Mar 16, 2010

Wait, the gentleman's telling me that never before in Federal law have we ordered people to buy a particular product, that we don't do that in Federal law as a routine matter?

govinfo.gov
Mar 11, 2010

It is clear that tort reform should be a part of this legislation, but of course it is not. I have tried to outline here, I told you that I had many, many kinds of special deals, backroom deals, behind the scenes deals--``change you can…

govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

Federal legislation already passed in 2006 offered all 50 States some Federal money to help set up the State high-risk pool to care for those people with preexisting conditions and offered Federal money to subsidize or to underwrite the…

govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

Ah, so it's Republicans who oppose this bill that are the pals of the health insurance industry? I don't think so. And you're telling me that in the one State where we've already tried this, a mandate that you must buy health insurance…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation