Political Quotes

John Shadegg: “It seems to me morally indefensible, morally indefensible to say to the American people, If you work for a big, big, big…”

On the recordMarch 16, 2010
It seems to me morally indefensible, morally indefensible to say to the American people, If you work for a big, big, big employer--like you and I do, the Federal Government--or like we'll say, General Motors or Intel or Motorola or AT&T or any of those big employers, you work for a big employer, you're a lucky guy or a lucky gal because your health insurance is tax free. Your employer buys the health insurance and writes off the cost of buying that health insurance. Your employer then gives that health insurance coverage to you, and it's not income to you. So the tax on-- we'll say, a $5,000 insurance policy--zero, zip, zero, nothing because you were lucky enough to go to work for a big employer. But the law in America--and I think this is what is morally indefensible.
Said by
John Shadegg
Arizona
Source
govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

Editor's note · Context

The speaker addresses the inequities in health insurance taxation between large and small employers.

Share

More from John Shadegg

Mar 16, 2010

Because of one word difference? One word difference. The Senate has already passed the Senate bill, the House has to pass that exact bill word for word. It can't have one word missing?

govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

No, we don't force people to do that. I guess we do say that if you want to drive in some places, you have to buy auto insurance to insure against damage to somebody else. Right?

govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

Ah, so it's Republicans who oppose this bill that are the pals of the health insurance industry? I don't think so. And you're telling me that in the one State where we've already tried this, a mandate that you must buy health insurance…

govinfo.gov
Mar 16, 2010

So this would be the first Federal mandate saying you must buy a product because the Federal Government tells you you must buy a product?

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation