On the recordJune 12, 2003
Whatever we do here today, let us be honest with the American people. Now, the gentleman from Massachusetts kept talking about the child tax credit. It is not a tax refund; it is not a tax credit. If we are going to do it, let us call it what it is, and it is welfare. When you get back money you have paid in, when we give the American people money they have paid in, that is a tax refund. That is a tax credit. When we take money away from some American taxpayers and we give it to someone else, that is not a tax credit. That is not a refund. That is welfare. And that is what you have proposed to do. If an American pays in $1,500 and we give them back $4,000, that $2,500 is not a refund; it is not a credit. It is someone else's money. And if we want to turn our Tax Code into a welfare system, let us be honest with the American people that that is what we are doing. That is what we are doing. Why represent this as a credit? Where is the credit? You pay in $1,500, you get back $3,000; $1,500 is a credit, but the other $1,500 is someone else's money. Today, of 100 American families, 50 of them paid 96.1 percent of the taxes before the last tax cut, and in the last tax cut, we gave Americans back their own money. And what the Democrats have proposed is taking Americans' money, your money, America, and we are giving it to someone else, and that is not a tax credit. That is welfare. Let us be honest with the American people.
Source
govinfo.gov




