Political Quotes

On the recordJanuary 29, 2020
I send a question to the desk. The CHIEF JUSTICE. Thank you. Senator Shelby's question is directed to counsel for the President: How does the noncriminal ``abuse of power'' standard advanced by the House Managers differ from ``maladministration''--an impeachment standard rejected by the Framers? Where is the line between such an ``abuse of power'' and a policy disagreement? Mr. Counsel DERSHOWITZ. Mr. Chief Justice, I will address this. Senators, thank you very much for that question because that question I think hits the key to the issue that is before you today. When the Founders rejected maladministration--and recall that it was introduced by Mason and rejected by Madison on the ground that it would turn our new Republic into a parliamentary democracy where a Prime Minister--in this case, a President--can be removed at the pleasure of the legislature. Remember, too, that in Britain, impeachment was not used against the Prime Minister, and neither was a vote of no confidence; it was used against lower level people. So maladministration was introduced by Mason, and Madison said no, it was just too vague and too general. What is maladministration? If you look it up in the dictionary and you look up synonyms, the synonyms include abuse, corruption, misrule, dishonesty, misuse of office, and misbehavior.…
Said by
Richard Shelby
Republican · Alabama

Share

More from Richard Shelby

Jun 6, 2022

Regrettably, this was all predictable and avoidable.

congress.gov
Dec 14, 2022

today I come to the Senate floor for what will probably be one of my last times--perhaps not my last time but close. I want to start off by thanking the people of Alabama, my home State. They have put their trust in me for more than 50…

govinfo.gov
May 25, 2022

Deterrence requires spending our limited resources on both offensive and defensive weapons.

congress.gov
Jun 6, 2022

Because the administration has refused to fund the construction of a comprehensive barrier along the border, it has been compelled to send the National Guard to deal with the consequences.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation