I considered this to be an extremely unfair bill. While it was titled the 'Product Liability Fairness' bill, there were numerous provisions that were one-sided and which attempted to take away rather basic rights of a claimant in a lawsuit, and I thought it was extremely unfair. Also this bill was unfair because of the fact that it exempted all commercial loss and made commercial loss come under the category of commercial or contract law, primarily the Uniform Commercial Code. Commercial loss is a business loss, not a personal injury loss. Some of the most egregious punitive damage suits--practically all of the large ones--have been against business. Penzoil versus Texaco, $11 billion, is the one that stands out primarily in the minds of most people. But commercial loss would be in most all instances restricted to corporate America suing corporate America. Manufacturers do not want to come under the provisions of this bill because they do not want to be put under the same laws as the people who receive personal injuries.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the fairness of the 'Product Liability Fairness' bill during a House debate.
Share
More from Howell Heflin
there is a little confusion as to which vote will be held, but I have to call this Santorum amendment the confusion amendment. We have, of course, argued in the past that we reformed it. And we have reformed it, the peanut program. But now…
The first amendment, I understand, that will be called up is one in which he alleges there is a conflict of interest in regard to the peanut program by the fact that co-ops and marketing associations which are run by farmers are involved…
As I understand it, this has been shown to the Department of Agriculture, and they have reservations pertaining to this. They are in the process right now of probably becoming involved in a lawsuit. Therefore, they object to it, and…
I rise today to support confirmation of Alan Greenspan's nomination to serve another term as Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors. Although I have not always been completely agreeable with his policies, I think that…





