Political Quotes

Douglas Alexander: “If the Senator would agree that all of those distinguished men and women with no prior judicial experience went on to…”

On the recordFebruary 12, 2003
If the Senator would agree that all of those distinguished men and women with no prior judicial experience went on to become distinguished members of the U.S. Supreme Court, then can the Senator help us understand why the Members of the other side suddenly think it is not just important but disqualifying for someone who is nominated for a lower court to have no judicial experience? Why is this suddenly a new criterion when many of the most distinguished jurists in our country's history have had a diverse background of experience? Why is this suddenly a new standard for Miguel Estrada?
Said by
Douglas Alexander
Labour Party

Editor's note · Context

Questioning the criteria for judicial nominations during a Senate debate.

Share

More from Douglas Alexander

Sep 27, 2026

Conference just last Thursday, the SNP-led Glasgow City Council attempted to fire and rehire more than 20,000 of their employees. This is happening not in 1926, conference, not 1926, but in 2026 conference. The SNP should hang their heads…

independent.co.uk
Oct 16, 2026

We are saying the time has come to think broadly about what should be our options.

thenational.scot
Oct 14, 2026

It’s no secret that I was not a supporter of leaving the European Union, and I called out early as trade minister what I described as the ‘post-imperial delusions’ of the Brexiteers.

theguardian.com

Other voices in this conversation