What can discipline do when tired troops have to make a supreme effort to reach the field of battle at a given hour?
Petr Alekseevich Kropotkin: “What can discipline do when tired troops have to make a supreme effort to reach the field of battle at a given hour?”
Editor's note · Context
Kropotkin questions the effectiveness of discipline when soldiers are exhausted and need to perform under pressure.
Share
More from Petr Alekseevich Kropotkin
Already during my stay at Clairvaux I saw the necessity of completely revising the formula itself of ‘struggle for existence’ in the animal world, and its applications to human affairs.
It is only the distribution which is defective; and if a social revolution took place, nothing more would be required than for everyone to return to his factory or workshop, Society taking possession for itself of the ‘surplus value’ or…
Most socialists had hitherto said that in our present civilized societies we actually produce much more than is necessary for guaranteeing full well-being to all.
I took a lively part in this movement, and with a few English comrades we started, in addition to the three socialist papers already in existence, an anarchist-communist monthly, ‘Freedom,’ which continues to live up to the present day.

