Political Quotes

On the recordMarch 3, 2010
At times we have talked in the past about this concept of constitutionality in two ways. One, that it violates the concepts of federalism. But the second one deals with specifically the commerce clause. I think that's been brought to our attention before. That even in court cases, and maybe somebody will correct me here when it's his turn, in court cases there are usually two principles that are involved on whether the commerce clause is justifiably used. One: Does it have an impact on interstate commerce? I think everybody admits this would have an impact on interstate commerce. But the second is: Is there a willing participant in this program? This is why this is different, because for the first time you are threatening to fine people, throw them in jail, for not doing anything. For doing nothing. I don't know how many negatives I put in those sentences. But for someone just living their life who does not want to participate, they will now be fined for doing that. The government has never done that. And that is what I think exacerbates and expands the commerce clause beyond recognition and beyond fairness to individuals at the same time.
Said by
Rob Bishop
Republican · Utah

Share & report

More from Rob Bishop

May 31, 2020

Instead, we decided to move ahead with what can only be described as really good political theater.

congress.gov
Jul 22, 2020

Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume. We have talked about several of the problems with this particular bill. With this particular bill, we have talked about how the poor reckoning of its sources there do not say what is…

Congressional Record · 2020-07-22
Jul 22, 2020

I am hopeful that more substantial progress to strengthen the power grid is forthcoming in the near future.

congress.gov
Oct 1, 2020

Mr. Speaker, since the minority leader is supportive, or I wouldn't be here, and I am the ranking member and I am supportive of it, and the Navajo Nation has been told. The chairman of the committee is in support of it, does that not…

Congressional Record · 2020-10-01

Other voices in this conversation