Political Quotes

On the recordJune 17, 2010
This is about making sure at the end of the day we stand up to big oil. I know there are those who suggest--my colleague from Louisiana has suggested he has a better way. The problem is his better way is constitutionally infirm. That has been reviewed by the Congressional Research Service which says that trying to enact legislation that effectively declares the guilt or imposes punishment on an identifiable individual or entity is in essence a bill of attainder under the Constitution; therefore, it cannot work. I have heard him say I don't want to come here and make a speech, I want to solve something. That is exactly the problem. That does not solve anything because it is constitutionally infirm, therefore it would not apply, therefore we would not have a success. Besides, if it is good enough for this incident, it is good enough for any other. Understanding that, I want to ensure we stand on the side with all of those commercial interests, so I ask unanimous consent--I take a final 30 seconds--I ask unanimous consent that the Environment and Public Works Committee be discharged of S. 3472, the Big Oil Bailout Prevention Unlimited Liability Act of 2010, and that the Senate proceed to its consideration; that the bill be read three times, passed, the motion to reconsider be laid upon the table, without intervening action or debate. The ACTING PRESIDENT pro tempore. Is there objection?
Said by
Bob Menendez
Democratic · New Jersey

Share & report

More from Bob Menendez

Sep 23, 2024

From your perspective, how has Boeing historically and more recently handled the tension between prioritizing safety while also being a moneymaking enterprise?

congress.gov
Apr 9, 2024

I think all of our immigration challenges that we have at the southern border deny one fact, that there are 25 million people in the southern hemisphere presently displaced from their country of origin, refugees seeking asylum or just…

congress.gov
Apr 15, 2024

Thank you for clarifying that point.

congress.gov
Jun 12, 2024

How do you think--in thinking about the existing infrastructure and making sure that we have an integrated transit system, how do we--should we be thinking about where there are gaps currently in service, or should we be thinking about…

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation