We just heard that a sixth grader could see that this is unconstitutional. However, a Harvard lawyer thought this was okay in April when it passed with only 11 dissenting votes, so to me, I believe that argument does not hold water. Tax-exempt status, Mr. Speaker, is not a constitutional right. It is not a constitutional right, but there is still robust due process protection in this bill that we worked out with our Democratic colleagues before passage in the Ways and Means Committee. That didn't stop, though, the gentleman from Maryland from voting in favor of these same exact identical provisions earlier this year. Mr. Speaker, I yield such time as he may consume to the gentleman from Pennsylvania (Mr. Smucker).
Jason Smith: “We just heard that a sixth grader could see that this is unconstitutional. However, a Harvard lawyer thought this was…”
On the recordNovember 21, 2024
Share
More from Jason Smith
Aug 21, 2026
Tax-exempt status is a privilege, not a right. When organizations that receive generous taxpayer-funded benefits refuse to comply with lawful congressional oversight about potential foreign influence, the American people have every right…
Aug 21, 2026
Make no mistake: Compliance with a congressional subpoena isn't optional, and the Committee will use all tools it has available to investigate whether foreign actors are exploiting our tax code to sow chaos and create division.
Jul 29, 2026
From the outside, it looks like a movement, but once you see how the money flows, it becomes clear that this is a machine.
Jul 31, 2026
It is clear the status quo is unacceptable. Tax-exempt status is a privilege, not a right.





