Political Quotes

On the recordApril 12, 2024
To hear the administration tell it, having to get a warrant is the end of the world. Well, guess what? In literally any other context in which law enforcement or intelligence agencies want to read an American's communications, they have to get a warrant. That has been the rule for over 200 years, and for 46 years the government has had to get a FISA title I order to read Americans' communications in a foreign intelligence investigation. These are investigations in which Americans are suspected of terrorism, espionage, cybercrimes--you name it. Somehow, a warrant or title I requirement is completely consistent with national security in those high-stakes cases, yet the administration and those who are opposed to this amendment allege it will plunge us into a dystopian nightmare if we apply this same basic longstanding protection to section 702 queries where the American often isn't even suspected of any wrongdoing at the time of the query. I don't buy it, and neither should you. Over a decade ago, as my friend Mr. Nadler said just a moment ago, a group of intelligence experts unanimously recommended requiring a warrant for U.S. person queries of section 702 data. That group included Michael Morell, former Acting Director of the CIA, and Richard A. Clarke, former Chief Counterterrorism Adviser to President George W. Bush--bipartisan--recommended the same thing that we have today. Mr. Chair, I reserve the balance of my time.
Said by
Andy Biggs
Republican · Arizona

Share

More from Andy Biggs

Jun 15, 2026

The Fourth Amendment is clear: the government must obtain a warrant before searching Americans' communications or personal data.

reason.com
Mar 6, 2025

Every one of you is exposed to criminal culpability here.

truthout.org
Jun 18, 2026

“I introduced legislation in Congress to bring down healthcare costs and also voiced support for Trump’s proposal to send money directly to Americans for health savings accounts so they can handle insurance and health costs as they see…

abcnews.com
Dec 4, 2024

I think the whole fricking American Community Survey should not be going forward.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation